Knicks Win Big as RJ Barrett’s Move to Toronto Backfires
What began as a routine day in December 2023 turned into a trade that would shape both the New York Knicks and Toronto Raptors for years. The Knicks sent RJ Barrett, Immanuel Quickley, and a second-round pick to Toronto in exchange for OG Anunoby, Precious Achiuwa, and Malachi Flynn. Now, nearly two years later, it’s clear which team emerged on top.
OG Anunoby and Achiuwa Shine for the Knicks
While Anunoby was the headline of the deal, Precious Achiuwa proved his worth as well. New York re-signed Anunoby to a five-year contract and Achiuwa to a one-year deal last summer. Though Achiuwa’s stint concluded at the end of last season, Anunoby continues to be a cornerstone of the Knicks’ roster.
For Toronto, Immanuel Quickley became the standout, re-signing on a five-year, $175 million deal last offseason. Despite being overshadowed by Barrett in New York, Quickley’s contract made him the headline for Toronto.
RJ Barrett’s Future in Toronto Remains Uncertain
Despite being the No. 3 pick in 2019, Barrett has struggled to find a long-term home in Toronto. After the Raptors acquired Brandon Ingram and extended him to a three-year deal, speculation mounted that Barrett could be on the move. Six months later, Barrett’s status remains in flux.
NBA insider Jake Fischer discussed Toronto’s plans on Bleacher Report’s Insider Notebook, noting that the Raptors aim to add veteran talent and contend in the Eastern Conference. Barrett is reportedly a “potential trade candidate” as Toronto eyes moves before next year’s deadline.
Interestingly, Barrett was considered during Toronto’s Ingram trade discussions with New Orleans, but the Pelicans passed—missing a chance to reunite him with Zion Williamson, whom the Knicks originally coveted in 2019.
Barrett’s Contract Makes Him Trade-Ready
Barrett has two years remaining on the four-year extension he signed with the Knicks in 2022, earning $27.7 million in 2025-26 and $29.6 million in 2026-27. That salary could make him a key asset for Toronto if they aim to acquire another star before the next trade deadline.
In hindsight, New York wasn’t criticized for including Barrett in the trade; most backlash centered on Quickley going to Toronto. The move made sense—the Knicks couldn’t guarantee Barrett the starting role he desired, so why pay him like one? Meanwhile, Quickley secured that type of contract with the Raptors.
Knicks Clearly Won the Trade
Barrett isn’t part of Toronto’s long-term plan, unlike Quickley. Despite improved production after the trade, he never fully met the expectations of a top-three pick in New York. The Raptors prioritized Ingram over Barrett, highlighting his uncertain role in Toronto’s future.
Even without a potential trade back to New York, the Knicks already know they won the deal, landing a core player in Anunoby and adding depth that has paid immediate dividends. Any move involving Barrett in Toronto would simply confirm what Knicks fans already know: this trade favored New York.
